Confused About a Guy? How to Cope & Tell if He’s Confused Too

PDF download Download Article
Decode your relationship with these practical tips
PDF download Download Article

Relationships with guys can be super confusing, no matter what stage you’re in. Whether you’re confused about where the two of you stand, you don’t know how you feel about him, or you’re looking for signs that he doesn’t know how he feels about you, you’ve come to the right place. In this article, we’ll cover everything so you can feel more secure about your relationship and decide what to do next.

Things You Should Know

  • If you’re confused about where the two of you stand, try journaling your thoughts and feelings, setting boundaries, and asking your friends for their opinions.
  • Make it clear to him what you expect from your relationship and give him space to figure out what he wants from your relationship.
  • Guys might be confused about their feelings for you if he doesn’t define your relationship, he acts hot and cold, or he behaves differently with you in public.
Section 1 of 3:

What to Do When You’re Confused About a Guy

PDF download Download Article
  1. Step 1 Write out your thoughts and feelings.
    If you’re not sure about where your relationship with him stands, or if you don’t know if you even like him, writing it out can help you sort out your feelings. Journal your feelings, give yourself time to process, and be okay with not having the answer right away. Journaling can be an incredibly powerful tool to help you manage your anxiety, reduce stress, and improve your mood by helping you prioritize your fears, problems, and concerns.[1] If you find it difficult to get your thoughts on paper, try these prompts:
    • What emotions come up when I think about this guy?
    • What do I like about him and what do I not like?
    • Why am I confused about my feelings for him?
  2. Step 2 Spend more time with him.
    It might be that you don’t know how you feel about this guy because you don’t know him well enough to decide one way or the other. Spending more time around him might help you understand who he is and where he’s coming from. If you’re a couple, spending quality time together can give you clarity about his thoughts, feelings, and decisions. Set aside time so the two of you can go out to dinner together, take a walk, or just hang out.[2]
    • Ask about his childhood, his favorite activities, and the things he likes (books, music, shows, movies, etc.) to start out with.
    • After you’ve skimmed the surface, ask questions that are a little more personal so you can tell if you want to pursue a deeper connection. What is he really passionate about? What does he value in a relationship? If money wasn’t a concern, where would he go and what would he do?[3]
    • Finding out what his political beliefs are can also help you decide if you're a good match. If your values and morals don’t line up, he might not be a great match.
    Advertisement
  3. Step 3 Notice if he adds positively to your life.
    You should feel validated, heard, acknowledged, safe, equal, and free around him. Do your mental health issues get worse around him? Does he care about your feelings? Does he give you the space you need? If your relationship doesn’t have healthy boundaries, communication, trust, and consent, then it might be a sign that he’s not the right guy for you.[4]
    • Setting boundaries can let your partner know your needs and let you know when something doesn’t feel right. Think about what you’re okay with and not okay with when it comes to physical, emotional, and sexual intimacy.
  4. Step 4 Notice the effortlessness of the conversations.
    Do you feel comfortable with him? Do you feel like you can tell him anything? If the answer to both those questions is no, why? Whether the two of you have been dating for years or just started dating, if there’s something about him that just doesn’t make you feel like you can let your guard down, it may be a sign that he’s not the one.[5]
    • If the two of you aren’t at the talking-every-night stage yet, pay attention to how often he tries to start a conversation—if he talks to you every chance he gets, it could mean that he likes you back.
  5. Step 5 Ask your friends what they think of him.
    Friends can be great resources when figuring out if a guy is a keeper. Because your friends are on the outside of your relationship and they care about your well-being, they may notice things that go right over your head. If you have a friend you feel comfortable with, tell them about your situation and see what they have to say.[6]
    • If you feel comfortable, and if you’re at a far enough stage in the relationship, you can also ask your friends to hang out with the two of you and do a fun activity together. That way, the guy you’re seeing can meet your friends (if he hasn’t already) and your friends can suss him out.
  6. Step 6 Pay attention to how he treats others.
    A great way to figure out how you feel about him is to notice how he behaves toward other people. Is he kind and respectful to waitstaff in restaurants? Is he polite to the people he meets? When he treats others badly, it may indicate a lack of integrity and empathy, which could later affect his relationship with you.[7]
    • Also pay attention to how he talks about other people. If he’s constantly negative or putting other people down, it could be a red flag.
  7. Step 7 Think about whether he’s supportive of you.
    In a loving relationship, both partners lift each other up when they’re feeling down. When you accomplish something, does he cheer you on? If he motivates you to achieve what you want and doesn’t judge, that might be a green flag.[8]
    • If the two of you aren’t in a relationship or if you just started dating, it could be hard to tell right away if he’s supportive or not. Observing how he treats his friends can give you some insight into how he’d treat you. Pay attention to how he talks to his friends when they succeed.
  8. Step 8 Prioritize your well-being.
    Whether you’re in a committed relationship or dating, it’s important to put yourself first and enjoy your life. If you’re the one who’s unsure about your relationship, take this time to explore other options and figure out what you do want. If you’re waiting for him to make a decision about your relationship, set a time frame for how long you’ll wait for an answer. In the meantime, go out, hang out with friends, have fun, and create new memories. Everything will work out in the end.[9]
    • If you’re attracted to a friend, it can be emotionally painful to keep up that relationship. Consider telling him how you feel, or if you want to keep the friendship the way it is, figure out a way to move on.
    • If the guy you’re talking to is committed to someone else, it might also be best to move on.
  9. Step 9 Think about whether or not you’re ready for a relationship.
    If you feel stuck and unsure about your relationship, you may need to ask yourself if you feel ready to enter a serious relationship right now. If not, no biggie! You don’t have to be ready if you don’t want to be. But if you’re dating, it might be better to let him know that sooner rather than later.[10]
    • If you want to find out whether you’re ready for a relationship, try our quiz!
    10. Advertisement
Section 2 of 3:

What to Do When a Guy Is Confused About You

PDF download Download Article
  1. Step 1 Tell him how you feel.
    Whether you’re just friends or already in a committed partnership, good communication is an integral part of any relationship. One of the best ways to understand how he feels is by telling him how you feel — you never know if what’s bothering you is bothering him too. If you’re already in a relationship, reassure him of your feelings for him. If you’ve just started dating, consider telling him how much he means to you.[11]
    • No matter how the conversation goes, you’re more likely to know what you want to do next after you’ve cleared the air.
  2. Step 2 Ask him what he expects from the relationship.
    It may be that you’re confused about what stage of the relationship the two of you are in, or whether he wants to commit to you or not. Either way, having a conversation about what he wants out of his relationship with you can help you figure out what step you’d like to take next. Whatever he says, accept his feelings and let him know that you care about what he wants.[12]
    • If the two of you know what you both want out of the relationship and he’s still acting hot and cold, use this conversation as a chance to ask for more consistency. Tell him what you’ve noticed and what bothers you about the way he’s been acting, and work together to figure out a solution.
  3. Step 3 Tell him what you expect from the relationship.
    If the two of you are in a non-committed relationship, there might be a miscommunication about what the two of you are looking for. If one of you wants to keep the relationship casual while the other wants to settle down and commit, you might be confused about where your relationship stands. Communicating what you’d like from your partner to them might help clear the air for both of you.[13]
    • If you want to keep the relationship casual and he wants to get more serious, tell him what exactly you’d like from him and draw boundaries. Do you want to get together every week? Do the two of you post pictures together? Do you hang out during hook-up sessions?
    • If you’re the one who wants to settle down, ask him if he’d like to take the relationship to the next level. Whichever direction he decides to go, you’ll have your answer.
  4. Step 4 Give him some space.
    If the guy you’re seeing is confused about what he wants, one of the best ways to help is by giving him space and staying busy in the meantime. Attempt to “positively distract” yourself from having confusing thoughts. Focus on taking care of yourself, staying positive, and engaging in activities you enjoy, and when he’s ready, he’ll let you know.[14]
    • If he’s acting hot and cold, backing off a little could make him realize what he’s missing and he might reach out to you.
    • If the two of you aren’t in a relationship yet, giving him space could also help you figure out if he likes you back. If he reaches out to you and makes more of an effort when you pull away, it might be a sign that he feels the same way about you.
    • Reader Poll: We asked 608 wikiHow readers about what led them to end a tricky romantic relationship, and 63% agreed that when it started to make them feel anxious or confused, that was the final straw. [Take Poll]
    • So if this is in line with how you're feeling, you're not alone.
    5. Advertisement


Section 3 of 3:

Signs a Guy Is Confused About His Feelings for You

PDF download Download Article
  1. Step 1 He doesn’t define his relationship with you.
    Maybe you haven’t had the “What are we?” conversation, or you have and he just doesn’t seem like he knows one way or the other. He might have had a bad breakup, or he’s just interested in something super casual. Whatever the situation, if a guy doesn’t seem ready to commit or doesn’t explicitly define his relationship with you, it could be a sign that he’s confused about his feelings for you.[15]
    • If you’re the only one reaching out and making plans, it could be a sign that you’re more interested in pursuing the relationship than he is.
  2. Step 2 He’s inconsistent, unpredictable, or unavailable.
    You might spend time in person together but never hear from him otherwise. He might be warm and welcoming to you one day, and then he’s cold and uninvolved the next. Maybe he sends you a random text out of nowhere after ghosting you for days. Whatever the case may be, he just isn’t reliable, which can make you wonder what he really wants, and can be a huge sign that he doesn’t know how he feels about you.[16]
  3. Step 3 He doesn’t put any work into the relationship.
    When it comes to a romantic partnership, you can’t carry both of you all the time. If the two of you are dating and he doesn’t put in any effort, arrange dates, do nice things for you, or communicate consistently, trust your gut and don’t ignore the red flags. If the two of you are just starting out and he doesn’t put in any work, it may be because he’s unsure about his feelings for you.[17]
  4. Step 4 He’s not vulnerable with you.
    Successful relationships require emotional connection, and being open is how you work toward that. If you’re dating or in a relationship and he’s not open with you, and especially if he expects you to be, it could mean that he’s confused about his feelings for you.[18]
    • If he’s vulnerable one day and cold the next, this could also mean that he’s confused about where the two of you stand in your relationship.
  5. Step 5 He only responds to texts or communicates when it’s convenient.
    Maybe you’re constantly waiting for him to text back, or he doesn’t follow up until days after your date together—we’ve all been there. However, if this is an ongoing issue, and he only texts you when it seems convenient for him, then it could mean that he’s not completely invested in the relationship.[19]
    • If he otherwise seems like he’s into you, it could be that he avoids texting back because he’s shy or afraid of rejection.
  6. Step 6 He doesn’t introduce you to his friends or family.
    It could be that you haven’t reached this part of the relationship yet, which is totally fine—go at your own pace. However, if you are in a committed relationship with him and you feel like you’re being hidden from the people he loves, it might be a red flag.[20] If he’s serious about your relationship, he should naturally want others to know that you two are together.
    • It might also be that he shows no interest in meeting your friends or family. Have a conversation with your partner so you can figure out why he feels this way—he might not be ready to move to that point in your relationship yet.
  7. Step 7 He flirts with other people.
    If you’re interested in someone who flirts with someone else in front of you, you might be unclear about where the two of you stand.[21] If you’re just starting to date or if you have a crush on him, this might be a sign that he’s confused about his feelings for you.
    • Pay attention to how he acts around you versus the people he flirts with. Does it seem like he’s more vulnerable with you? Could he be flirting as a joke? Or is he always dating or hooking up with these other people? Noticing how he acts around others could help you figure out if he likes you back.
  8. Step 8 He’s all-in for a period of time, but then becomes completely cold.
    It might be that he wants you to notice him but doesn’t seem to know what to do after you do. In this case, he might just be confused about his feelings for you. However, it could also be that he’s doing a form of breadcrumbing, or leading you on but not communicating enough to form an actual relationship.[22] If you feel like you’re being breadcrumbed, it’s totally not your fault. But, it may be a sign that it’s time to move on and date someone who does want to settle down.
  9. Step 9 He makes sure you know he isn’t seeing anybody.
    Guys who secretly like you might downplay their connections to other people and emphasize that he’s not pursuing anyone romantically. He wants to make sure that you know he’s available. If he doesn’t make a move, even when he knows that you know he’s available, it might be because he’s shy or because he hasn’t quite worked out his feelings for you yet.
  10. Step 10 He tries to make you jealous.
    While some guys downplay their relationships and make it clear that they’re available, others do the complete opposite. He might not correct anyone who says he’s dating other people, or he might flirt with or talk about people he finds attractive. He may act this way because he wants to make you jealous and feels frustrated or confused about his feelings for you.
    • To make sure that his intention is to make you jealous, watch how he acts around the people he finds attractive. If he ignores their advances or refuses to go on dates while you're around, then he might be interested in you.
  11. Step 11 He behaves differently in public.
    It can be confusing when his actions don’t match his words. It might be that he won’t show affection in public but has no problem doing it when you’re alone. He might tell you he misses you and that he enjoys getting to know you, but in public, he acts like he doesn’t want to be seen with you.[23]
    • This behavior can definitely hurt. If he acts this way, try to have a conversation about his behavior and tell him how it makes you feel. If he keeps pretending you don’t exist, even after the two of you have a talk, it may be time to move on to greener pastures.
    • He might deny it when others talk about the chemistry you two have, which can also be a sign that he’s confused about his feelings for you.
  12. Step 12 He compliments you but doesn’t say he loves you.
    If you two have been in a relationship for a while, it might be that he showers you with compliments but never says the magical words “I love you.” This might be because he’s shy or waiting for you to make the first move, or it might be because he’s confused about how he feels.
    • If he gives you little gifts, says sweet things, and constantly supports you, but doesn’t say whether he’s interested in you, it could be a sign that he does have feelings for you.
  13. Step 13 He messages you often but avoids discussing plans.
    Maybe he finds ways to spend time together but doesn’t ask you out on a date, or maybe he says he loved spending time with you after your date but takes a week to contact you. It can be hard to see where the two of you stand if he seems to be interested in you, but doesn’t act on his feelings.[24]
    • He might also avoid making plans if he’s shy, if he’s not ready, or if he’s afraid to commit to a relationship. If he seems to be interested in you and the two of you are close, try asking him if he wants to take the relationship slower.
  14. Step 14 His body language says he’s into you, but he doesn’t admit it.
    Observing someone’s body language can clue you into what they’re really thinking. Eye contact can lead to moments of chemistry, so if he stares at you but looks away when your eyes meet, it could mean that he doesn’t want to have feelings for you, or that he doesn’t want you to know that these feelings exist.
    • He might also get close to you and pull away suddenly. Skin contact can also reveal whether you’re attracted to someone, so if he pulls away it might mean that he’s afraid of revealing his true feelings.
    • If you sit or stand a certain way, or move your hands, you may notice that he does the same thing — mirroring body language can mean that he’s interested in you.
    • A guy who’s interested in you will also face you when you two are talking. He might turn his entire body toward you or just his feet, and he may position himself closer to you.
  15. Step 15 He’s always watching your social media.
    He might pop up on your Instagram story as soon as you post them or DM you when you post pictures on Instagram. But then, he doesn't respond back when you DM him. This could definitely be a sign that he’s confused about his relationship with you.[25]
    • If you have pictures on your social media of you and another person, he may be playing it cool because he thinks you are already in a relationship. If you think this is the case, try making it clear on your socials that you and the other person aren’t dating, or casually mention that you’re single in conversation.
  16. Step 16 He doesn’t seem to pay attention but still remembers everything.
    Guys who have a crush on you will pay close attention to you and remember details about you and the things you say. If he acts cool and unattached but still remembers what your favorite snack is or what you did over the weekend, it could mean that he is interested in you, but he doesn’t know what that means to him yet.
  17. Step 17 He asks you lots of personal questions.
    Sometimes, it can be unclear if a guy is actually interested in you and your life, or if he’s just being friendly. If a guy is confused about his feelings for you, he might ask a lot of personal questions, but won’t make a move or ask you out. The good news is that if he takes the initiative to learn more about you, he may have feelings for you.
  18. Step 18 He seems protective of you.
    If he’s confused about his feelings for you, he might not tell you he likes you but will take extra steps to protect your well-being. He might walk you to your door, text or call to make sure you got home safe, or defend you against people who are mean to you.[26]
    • If he seems extra possessive of you and restricts what you do or who you see, this could be a major red flag. Be cautious if he seems overly protective. If the two of you are in a relationship, have a conversation with him to make sure he’s not restricting your freedom.
  19. Step 19 He balances a compliment with a tease.
    To some people, this may seem like a red flag, but if the two of you are in a relationship, teasing can be a sign that he feels completely comfortable around you. If the two of you aren’t dating yet and he teases you and compliments you in the same conversation, it may be because he’s not confident enough to tell you how he feels.[27]
    • If you two are in the early stages of your relationship, he may be trying to draw the two of you closer by showing that he’s paid enough attention to pick up on what you’re secure and insecure about. In other words, he knows what to tease about, and what to stay away from.
  20. Step 20 Your conversations just suddenly die.
    If you two are dating and your conversations just suddenly seem to stop, it could be a sign that he’s unsure about where your relationship stands.[28] Or, if you two are in the talking phase and he suddenly ghosts you, it could mean he’s afraid of being vulnerable with you. If this happens to you, don't take it personally—he may just need time to sort out his feelings.
    21. Advertisement


Expert Q&A

Ask a Question
200 characters left
Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered.
Submit
Advertisement

Tips

Submit a Tip
All tip submissions are carefully reviewed before being published
Name
Please provide your name and last initial
Submit
Thanks for submitting a tip for review!

You Might Also Like

Kiss
How to
Kiss
Turn a Guy On
How to
Turn on a Guy
Impress a Girl with Words
How to
Impress a Girl with Words
Birthday Wishes for Girlfriend100+ Loving, Funny & Appreciative Birthday Wishes for Your Girlfriend
What Are the Bases in DatingWhat Are the Bases in a Relationship? Defining the Baseball-Sex Metaphor
Know if Your Girlfriend Is Horny
How to
Tell if Your Girlfriend Is Horny: 12 Signs She's Turned On
Good Morning Message to Make Her Smile100+ Good Morning Texts for Her (& Other Ways to Make Her Smile)
Make a Girl Feel Special Through Text
How to
Make a Girl Feel Special Through Text
Happy One Month AnniversaryCelebrate Your One Month Anniversary with These Sweet Messages
Flirty Questions to Ask a GirlQuestions to Ask a Girl to Increase Intimacy
Show Appreciation for Your Girlfriend in Words11+ Heartfelt Messages to Make Your Girlfriend Feel Appreciated
Signs Your Ex Will Eventually Come BackSigns Your Ex Will Eventually Come Back
What's a Story to Tell Your Girlfriend15 Sweet and Romantic Stories to Tell Your Girlfriend
Drinking Games for CouplesThe 25 Best (and Spiciest) Drinking Games to Play as a Couple
Advertisement

Expert Interview

Thanks for reading our article! If you’d like to learn more about relationship stages, check out our in-depth interview with Kim Chronister, PsyD.

References

  1. ↑ https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?ContentID=4552&ContentTypeID=1
  2. ↑ https://www.cosmopolitan.com/sex-love/a17884344/signs-youre-in-the-right-relationship/
  3. ↑ https://www.womenshealthmag.com/sex-and-love/a34026473/questions-to-ask-your-crush/
  4. ↑ https://www.ny.gov/teen-dating-violence-awareness-and-prevention/what-does-healthy-relationship-look
  5. ↑ https://www.cosmopolitan.com/sex-love/a17884344/signs-youre-in-the-right-relationship/
  6. ↑ https://www.cosmopolitan.com/sex-love/a17884344/signs-youre-in-the-right-relationship/
  7. ↑ https://psychcentral.com/lib/why-do-some-people-lack-empathy
  8. ↑ https://www.romper.com/p/9-signs-youre-in-a-supportive-relationship-14332
  9. ↑ https://www.doctorforlove.com/when-a-man-is-confused-about-what-he-wants/
  1. ↑ https://exploringyourmind.com/am-i-emotionally-ready-for-a-new-relationship/
  2. ↑ https://psychcentral.com/blog/how-to-express-emotions-in-relationships
  3. ↑ https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/in-the-name-love/202206/how-one-night-stands-turn-something-more
  4. ↑ https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/relationships-and-communication
  5. ↑ https://www.idiva.com/relationships-love/relationships/what-to-do-when-your-man-is-confused-about-the-relationship/17075274
  6. ↑ https://www.womenshealthmag.com/relationships/a29473354/mixed-signals-meaning/
  7. ↑ https://psychcentral.com/blog/feeling-trapped-or-abandoned-when-relationships-run-hot-or-cold#1
  8. ↑ https://www.eviemagazine.com/post/confused-about-your-relationship-status-look-for-these-3-signs-of-commitment
  9. ↑ https://www.womenshealthmag.com/relationships/a29473354/mixed-signals-meaning/
  10. ↑ https://www.womenshealthmag.com/relationships/a29473354/mixed-signals-meaning/
  11. ↑ https://www.eviemagazine.com/post/confused-about-your-relationship-status-look-for-these-3-signs-of-commitment
  12. ↑ https://psychcentral.com/relationships/flirting-is-cheating
  13. ↑ https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/breadcrumbing
  14. ↑ https://www.womenshealthmag.com/relationships/a29473354/mixed-signals-meaning/
  15. ↑ https://psychcentral.com/blog/love-matters/2018/07/16-signs-of-an-avoidant-or-unavailable-partner#5
  16. ↑ https://www.womenshealthmag.com/relationships/a29473354/mixed-signals-meaning/
  17. ↑ https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/love-digitally/202003/what-determines-jealous-protective-behaviour-in-men
  18. ↑ https://www.today.com/health/he-flirting-me-how-be-certain-he-s-really-you-t74856
  19. ↑ https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/22/smarter-living/why-people-ghost-and-how-to-get-over-it.html

About This Article

Kim Chronister, PsyD
Co-authored by:
Kim Chronister, PsyD
Clinical Psychologist
This article was co-authored by Kim Chronister, PsyD and by wikiHow staff writer, Cheyenne Main. Dr. Kim Chronister is a Licensed Clinical Psychologist. She specializes in helping people struggling with substance abuse, relationship problems, eating disorders, and personality disorders. Dr. Chronister has contributed to and appeared on Access Hollywood, Investigation Discovery, and NBC News. She is the author of “Peak Mindset” and “FitMentality.” She holds an MA in Clinical Psychology and a Doctor of Psychology (PsyD) from Alliant International University. This article has been viewed 22,299 times.
5 votes - 48%
Co-authors: 6
Updated: August 8, 2024
Views: 22,299
Categories: Relationships
Thanks to all authors for creating a page that has been read 22,299 times.

Did this article help you?

Advertisement